I think Firedrake might come around soon, if only because he seems like the kind of person that usually needs a bonk on the head to be convinced to pay attention. Neuro-whatsit seems to be at least trying to take an objective approach on this page (ie asking questions first), but I’m just waiting for Conjurer to do something stupid in a frustrated attempt to prove his superiority.
Actually, Neuronet actually came out pretty reasonable in this scene, and even took Julie’s side of the argument. That said, I’m not sure if he was on Julie’s side or still a bit annoyed at the Conjuror making himself the leader. I can see him switching over to Julie’s faction just to annoy the magician.
Veritas
Neuronet isn’t in his element here. Conjurer is rather foolishly certain that he is, and is getting overconfident, but Neuronet is at least a bit more aware that this is not the world he knows. While he hasn’t shown clear signs of not thinking of Julie as just a kid (could be he respects Phlogiston saying it more than he would if Julie had been the only one), he otherwise seems less inclined to assume things, and thus is talking more about the things he knows to be true: that they’re in a giant magic egg, not the normal world; that 84 and Phlogiston got “ahead” of the others, without assuming they did so by merely flying quickly ahead (which he’d likely have seen anyway, right?).
Perhaps I’m reading too much into it. Anyway, he does seem much more likely than Conjurer to acknowledge that ANYONE else, 84 included, may have a point; but how much he actually respects her remains to be seen.
Actually, Superman is usually pretty sharp. It’s just that his intelligence isn’t what leads to his most memorable displays the way Batman’s does. 84 is Superman dealing with being underestimated because she is a young girl rather than a grown man, which leads to a level of snark Superman doesn’t feel the need to dish out.
Julie is just being careful and using common sense. Conjurer seems to be intent on analyzing everything like some kind of magic CSI while Julie just sees a riddle being presented and is going for an Occam’s Razor approach (like her demonstration of the loop at Firedrake’s expense). The simplest solution/explanation is often the correct one, particularly with the type of puzzles and riddles that most trickster types like Veles seem overly fond of.
In D&D terms Julie’s acting like somebody with high wisdom and moderate intelligence while Conjurer is over thinking the issue with (supposedly) epic intelligence but apparently dismal wisdom. And the charisma of a ticked off chihuahua.
Actually the ticked off Chihuahua would have a higher charisma at this point.
Mechwarrior
Yeah, his charisma score seems closer to that of an incontinent chihuahua.
Prairie Son
I’d rather see an incontinent Chihuahua on my new carpet than any of these adults. Well, I might make an exception for Phlo, but I’m not sure she wouldn’t wreck the carpet because of her powers.
That’s not quite what Occam’s Razor is, which is the simplest explanation that explains the most facts is the correct one. 84 is looking at things from a more straightforward ‘there’s likely a common sense answer to the various trials’ while Neuronet and Conjurer are vastly over-thinking things (although Conjurer was at least willing to promptly accept the evidence they were in a spacial loop after previously making himself look stupid with his pontificating about his ‘finely tuned senses’). Firedrake and Phlogiston are more going with the flow at the moment, with Phlogiston trying to be peacemaker and get everyone working together instead of at odds.
And Neuronet pointed out that they are currently in a totally magic environment which might probably screws up any magic perception checks because everything’s magic.
JJ
Player: “I would like to try to detect magic, what should I roll?”
DM: Don’t bother, you detect magic.
Mechwarrior
Actually, Occam’s Razor is using the fewest and smallest unknown variables that fit the situation.
This is why “God did it” is never considered to be an acceptable answer under Occam’s Razor: while it’s a simple explanation, it has an unknown variable of effectively infinite size.
Aw, why’d it have to hit the guy who least deserved it?
I have to concur with Moe Lane’s statement a couple pages ago that Conjurer’s helmet just seems tailor made to flip off with one good smack to the back at the right angle…
He’s also the only one with an unshielded head for the rock joke to work best with.
Yhelta
I disagree. The Conjurer’s helmet would have provided a very satisfying KLONG sound.
kentda
While it did make sense to whack Firedrake in terms of the joke, I still would have preferred a clong sound on Conjurer’s helmet. So much more amusing.
Except that’s a valid question to be asking, when presented with a claim you want to know by what evidence they arrived at that conclusion. Unlike Conjurer whose response was ‘What Hokem! I’m too good to not notice something like that!’ response. Neuronet meanwhile is fed up with Conjurer’s attitude and quickly points out that they aren’t in the universe he’s used to.
Drojem
His question sounds like he’s still doubting whether it really is the case. But Phlogiston and 84 just stood in one spot and: Hey look! Guess what happened? Which is all the evidence they needed, so that’s how they know. 84 didn’t have to know before she stopped: she had a hypothesis and tested it by stopping. Firedrake was being both dense and stubborn.
As they go along he seems to be getting more focused on the task they have and caring less about one of them being a kid or a FISS particularly since she’s proving herself with her actions (and Conjurer’s alienating him with his attitude).
Oh, I get it! I am SOOO dense, I can’t believe I didn’t get this before! (I haven’t bought a regular comic or even been in a comic for a long time, so I don’t know if the PS238s that are online have been published in hard copy or not. So this is ENTIRELY speculation on my part.)
84 is going to become the next Atlas, isn’t she? Consider:
* She’s smart. She is not taking anything for granted in the egg, which is allowing her to outthink the “more experienced” supers during this challenge.
* She is respected among other F.I.S.S.s. The website Atlas 2 set up is getting quite a following, and it looks like she is on her way to earning the respect of supers community, both the hero and villain sides.
* Atlas 2 doesn’t WANT to be Atlas, and is rather incompetent at the job, which is why 84 is training him.
* Although she’s chosen the hero name “84”, that only means something to the hero community, specifically the F.I.S.S. subsection of it. If she gains widespread public recognition, the number won’t have any relevance to the world at large. I could see her taking the mantle of Atlas, but preferring to be called 84 within hero circles.
If this was already brought up in the comments, well, I often forget to read them as well. 🙂
I just look at it as Atlas and the other important FISS that fought in the past. Both of them fought not for fame, but because it was considered the right action at the time. They saw the dangers around them, but didn’t blindly ignore the threats. Our old variant kept his flight hidden and had humility as he was a descent guy.
Atlas on the other had came from another world as he was taught the “Super Morals” as he did go with a descent life… only to have a marriage break up and villain come and try to steal his son. (both evil school and his own home planet.)
That leaves someone with a descent set of morals, combine with logic, then wrap it up with a descent amount of mental strength (achieved from her past adventures and a moonshadow confidence boost), with just a dash of that extra something… mostly given by having to work with villains and seeing the world in “regular vision” instead of “super vision”.
Need an example of super vision? Take a look at the circle problem. When told what was going on it was split up. Normal vision – A child figured this out before me? That can’t be right? — Super vision – My ultra fancy super powers didn’t say anything so obviously I must be right. — her vision – Drat I missed the metal helmet with that rock throw.
KillerFish
I believe you mean Mr. Extraordinary?
But you’re right. it’s not the power-set, it’s the moral decency of the person that makes them a hero.
84 is basically a Supergirl, just as Moonshadow is basically a Robin. 84 “growing up” to be Atlas (Superman) would make perfect sense. I think, however, that she’d feel stuck with the 84 name, otherwise we’d be letting down “her people”.
Then again, maybe 81 would take over the leadership of the F.I.S.S. community and give her a big send-off party into the Atlas identiry. He might regard her getting the “job” as “validation” for the F.I.S.S.es, the same way comic fans feel that their favorite comic-book being made into a movie somehow shows how great they are, instead of how much money the movie makers think they can make from them.
The basic difference between the F.I.S.S. community and Atlas is that the F.I.S.S. people are humans who have those powers as part of the appearance of super powers on Earth, while Atlas is a guy from another planet whose powers have a different origin. We discovered in the comic that “Argonite” affects any F.I.S.S., but we’ve never been told whether eveybody knows that, or just the people who were there when Atlas exposed the bad guy from Argo to the argonite, and 84 was affected as well. It might affect public perceptions to know that every F.I.S.S. is basically an Atlas. But would it raise people’s opinions of the F.I.S.S. community, or lower their esteem for Atlas?
I was rereading that story arc recently and the general comments that it affecting other F.I.S.S. was an accident but they need(ed) a control incase the F.I.S.S. got out of hand as they did on Argo.
As drawn, Julie has blank eyes. So does Phlogiston. So do the others except for Neurowhoosit. Does that mean he’ll be the one who is killed (or severely incapacitated)?
It could not have circled the earth that quickly without burning up in the atmosphere. Any slower and it would have fallen and hit the ground short. Any faster it would have continued out into space never to return.
Then again maybe it’s magic.
Yeah, don’t you read the “what if?” section of xkcd? The part where real-life science is used on comic-book situations, I check it frequently for new entries.
I believe that the eye that they are seeking is the “third eye” that sees inward, seeing through illusion to truth, seeing one’s own flaws instead of being self-deceived, yada, yada, yada. That would explain the Tarot cards since references on the internet refer to the tarot as a means of strenghening the third eye. The hypothesis will be strengthened if the gatekeeper shows up carrying a crystal ball.
I also think that the locks and obstacles will be overcome by positive character traits, such as courage (stepping on the stone to open the door), honesty (getting her past the stone golems), leadership (she already has two of the others viewing her as competent), observation (noticing the spatial loop), and politeness (the gatekeeper giving her information). I expect further obstacles to be solved by kindness, charity, mercy, humility, loyalty, etc.
Crap, you may be close on that. Anyone here remember the Ultima series? In particular, Ultima IV – Quest of the Avatar? This is starting to sound like the learning the 8 virtues of the avatar and becoming the embodiment of them from the game.
Grigor is the “Doorman.” He doesn’t move from his book under the bridge.
This is probably the “Babysitter.”
(Who is likely to be one of Grigor’s relatives, and 84 scores again for knowing Grigor’s name.)
He’s probably referencing the Holodeck, which used a treadmill-like effect to keep people from walking into the camouflaged walls. (That was the story in the pilot episode, at least. Given some of what they do in the Holodeck, it gets a little hard to justify.)
I don’t think 84 could have aimed that rock, so I’m assuming it’s the egg world warping things to hit Firedrake. As for why Firedrake deserved the rock: He’s the one who’s proved he’s not really listening to 84. Conjuror may be dismissing what she said, but he at least listened. Neuro is considering it. Firedrake just heard ‘warping’ and ignored the part about the fact that 84 getting ahead of them by just standing still.
98 thoughts on “2015-01-09”
Random Wanderer
Snrk.
Does anyone think they’ll learn to actually take Julie’s word for something by the time they reach the end of the test?
Flushmaster
I think Firedrake might come around soon, if only because he seems like the kind of person that usually needs a bonk on the head to be convinced to pay attention. Neuro-whatsit seems to be at least trying to take an objective approach on this page (ie asking questions first), but I’m just waiting for Conjurer to do something stupid in a frustrated attempt to prove his superiority.
Mutant for Hire
Actually, Neuronet actually came out pretty reasonable in this scene, and even took Julie’s side of the argument. That said, I’m not sure if he was on Julie’s side or still a bit annoyed at the Conjuror making himself the leader. I can see him switching over to Julie’s faction just to annoy the magician.
Veritas
Neuronet isn’t in his element here. Conjurer is rather foolishly certain that he is, and is getting overconfident, but Neuronet is at least a bit more aware that this is not the world he knows. While he hasn’t shown clear signs of not thinking of Julie as just a kid (could be he respects Phlogiston saying it more than he would if Julie had been the only one), he otherwise seems less inclined to assume things, and thus is talking more about the things he knows to be true: that they’re in a giant magic egg, not the normal world; that 84 and Phlogiston got “ahead” of the others, without assuming they did so by merely flying quickly ahead (which he’d likely have seen anyway, right?).
Perhaps I’m reading too much into it. Anyway, he does seem much more likely than Conjurer to acknowledge that ANYONE else, 84 included, may have a point; but how much he actually respects her remains to be seen.
Van
No. They have yet to pass a perception test to notice that they are idiots.
KillerFish
DM: “Roll a save vs. ego. Make it a good one.”
Van
DM: “You rolled a 1, critical failure, geeze, your character has an ego worse than a dragon, and proceeds to prove it.”
Matt [in Middletown]
Does that involve any gazebos, gongs, or doors in the immediate vicinity?
“Too late.. the gazebo catches you and eats you.”
AgentKeen
Sometimes the hammer can do just as good a job as the finely tuned instrument.
You’ll just get hurt if you aren’t careful.
Veritas
Re: the first, especially if your problem is a nail sticking up.
Megamieuwsel
That was pretty good aimin’ !
Sora2455
Well, thats one way to prove a point…
anon
So, 84 is like a little bit of batman stapled onto superman? Isn’t that like giving batman a green lantern ring?
mage_cat
Actually, Superman is usually pretty sharp. It’s just that his intelligence isn’t what leads to his most memorable displays the way Batman’s does. 84 is Superman dealing with being underestimated because she is a young girl rather than a grown man, which leads to a level of snark Superman doesn’t feel the need to dish out.
Moe Lane
True. Also, Superman is often working *with* Batman, who pretty much operates at 11/10 analytic capacity at all times.
Flushmaster
Julie is just being careful and using common sense. Conjurer seems to be intent on analyzing everything like some kind of magic CSI while Julie just sees a riddle being presented and is going for an Occam’s Razor approach (like her demonstration of the loop at Firedrake’s expense). The simplest solution/explanation is often the correct one, particularly with the type of puzzles and riddles that most trickster types like Veles seem overly fond of.
In D&D terms Julie’s acting like somebody with high wisdom and moderate intelligence while Conjurer is over thinking the issue with (supposedly) epic intelligence but apparently dismal wisdom. And the charisma of a ticked off chihuahua.
Van
Actually the ticked off Chihuahua would have a higher charisma at this point.
Mechwarrior
Yeah, his charisma score seems closer to that of an incontinent chihuahua.
Prairie Son
I’d rather see an incontinent Chihuahua on my new carpet than any of these adults. Well, I might make an exception for Phlo, but I’m not sure she wouldn’t wreck the carpet because of her powers.
Nightmask
That’s not quite what Occam’s Razor is, which is the simplest explanation that explains the most facts is the correct one. 84 is looking at things from a more straightforward ‘there’s likely a common sense answer to the various trials’ while Neuronet and Conjurer are vastly over-thinking things (although Conjurer was at least willing to promptly accept the evidence they were in a spacial loop after previously making himself look stupid with his pontificating about his ‘finely tuned senses’). Firedrake and Phlogiston are more going with the flow at the moment, with Phlogiston trying to be peacemaker and get everyone working together instead of at odds.
Opus the Poet
And Neuronet pointed out that they are currently in a totally magic environment which might probably screws up any magic perception checks because everything’s magic.
JJ
Player: “I would like to try to detect magic, what should I roll?”
DM: Don’t bother, you detect magic.
Mechwarrior
Actually, Occam’s Razor is using the fewest and smallest unknown variables that fit the situation.
This is why “God did it” is never considered to be an acceptable answer under Occam’s Razor: while it’s a simple explanation, it has an unknown variable of effectively infinite size.
Nico
That’s some pretty decent aim there, 84!
Psiberkiwi
“I threw a rock into the air… and when it came down, it split Firedrake’s hair…”
Shadur
Aw, why’d it have to hit the guy who least deserved it?
I have to concur with Moe Lane’s statement a couple pages ago that Conjurer’s helmet just seems tailor made to flip off with one good smack to the back at the right angle…
Ghostbear0
Because he is the one who projects young jock and is most acsesible to go all locker room on. Also he is the last one to say something really dumb.
Russell White
Also, he’s the only one not wearing a helmet,so it’s funnier
Nightmask
He’s also the only one with an unshielded head for the rock joke to work best with.
Yhelta
I disagree. The Conjurer’s helmet would have provided a very satisfying KLONG sound.
kentda
While it did make sense to whack Firedrake in terms of the joke, I still would have preferred a clong sound on Conjurer’s helmet. So much more amusing.
maarvarq
I think saying “How could she know…?” earned him that.
Nightmask
Except that’s a valid question to be asking, when presented with a claim you want to know by what evidence they arrived at that conclusion. Unlike Conjurer whose response was ‘What Hokem! I’m too good to not notice something like that!’ response. Neuronet meanwhile is fed up with Conjurer’s attitude and quickly points out that they aren’t in the universe he’s used to.
Drojem
His question sounds like he’s still doubting whether it really is the case. But Phlogiston and 84 just stood in one spot and: Hey look! Guess what happened? Which is all the evidence they needed, so that’s how they know. 84 didn’t have to know before she stopped: she had a hypothesis and tested it by stopping. Firedrake was being both dense and stubborn.
Moe Lane
I think that Neuronet is maybe starting to come around.
Nightmask
As they go along he seems to be getting more focused on the task they have and caring less about one of them being a kid or a FISS particularly since she’s proving herself with her actions (and Conjurer’s alienating him with his attitude).
DocSavage
It’s very hard to aim when you are throwing away from someone. =)
Mechwarrior
Fortunately, dramatic irony is a strong attractive force in this dimension.
Yhelta
Elan would be proud…
CraigR
Oh, I get it! I am SOOO dense, I can’t believe I didn’t get this before! (I haven’t bought a regular comic or even been in a comic for a long time, so I don’t know if the PS238s that are online have been published in hard copy or not. So this is ENTIRELY speculation on my part.)
84 is going to become the next Atlas, isn’t she? Consider:
* She’s smart. She is not taking anything for granted in the egg, which is allowing her to outthink the “more experienced” supers during this challenge.
* She is respected among other F.I.S.S.s. The website Atlas 2 set up is getting quite a following, and it looks like she is on her way to earning the respect of supers community, both the hero and villain sides.
* Atlas 2 doesn’t WANT to be Atlas, and is rather incompetent at the job, which is why 84 is training him.
* Although she’s chosen the hero name “84”, that only means something to the hero community, specifically the F.I.S.S. subsection of it. If she gains widespread public recognition, the number won’t have any relevance to the world at large. I could see her taking the mantle of Atlas, but preferring to be called 84 within hero circles.
If this was already brought up in the comments, well, I often forget to read them as well. 🙂
cherub
The PS238s have all been published except the story that is currently being told. Arron will probably publish this one once it is done.
and you could be right 84 is on that path, Becoming Velles opponent would be one more step on that path.
ThatGuy
I just look at it as Atlas and the other important FISS that fought in the past. Both of them fought not for fame, but because it was considered the right action at the time. They saw the dangers around them, but didn’t blindly ignore the threats. Our old variant kept his flight hidden and had humility as he was a descent guy.
Atlas on the other had came from another world as he was taught the “Super Morals” as he did go with a descent life… only to have a marriage break up and villain come and try to steal his son. (both evil school and his own home planet.)
That leaves someone with a descent set of morals, combine with logic, then wrap it up with a descent amount of mental strength (achieved from her past adventures and a moonshadow confidence boost), with just a dash of that extra something… mostly given by having to work with villains and seeing the world in “regular vision” instead of “super vision”.
Need an example of super vision? Take a look at the circle problem. When told what was going on it was split up. Normal vision – A child figured this out before me? That can’t be right? — Super vision – My ultra fancy super powers didn’t say anything so obviously I must be right. — her vision – Drat I missed the metal helmet with that rock throw.
KillerFish
I believe you mean Mr. Extraordinary?
But you’re right. it’s not the power-set, it’s the moral decency of the person that makes them a hero.
Leo Orionis
84 is basically a Supergirl, just as Moonshadow is basically a Robin. 84 “growing up” to be Atlas (Superman) would make perfect sense. I think, however, that she’d feel stuck with the 84 name, otherwise we’d be letting down “her people”.
Then again, maybe 81 would take over the leadership of the F.I.S.S. community and give her a big send-off party into the Atlas identiry. He might regard her getting the “job” as “validation” for the F.I.S.S.es, the same way comic fans feel that their favorite comic-book being made into a movie somehow shows how great they are, instead of how much money the movie makers think they can make from them.
The basic difference between the F.I.S.S. community and Atlas is that the F.I.S.S. people are humans who have those powers as part of the appearance of super powers on Earth, while Atlas is a guy from another planet whose powers have a different origin. We discovered in the comic that “Argonite” affects any F.I.S.S., but we’ve never been told whether eveybody knows that, or just the people who were there when Atlas exposed the bad guy from Argo to the argonite, and 84 was affected as well. It might affect public perceptions to know that every F.I.S.S. is basically an Atlas. But would it raise people’s opinions of the F.I.S.S. community, or lower their esteem for Atlas?
Kaian
I was rereading that story arc recently and the general comments that it affecting other F.I.S.S. was an accident but they need(ed) a control incase the F.I.S.S. got out of hand as they did on Argo.
=Tamar
As drawn, Julie has blank eyes. So does Phlogiston. So do the others except for Neurowhoosit. Does that mean he’ll be the one who is killed (or severely incapacitated)?
Unmaker
It’s their masks or lack thereof, except perhaps for Phlogiston. I don’t think it is a deliberate tell.
Mechwarrior
Yeah, Aaron draws eyes like that on a very frequent basis in this comic.
Andorxor
That does proves nothing,she is a F.I.S.S. she could have thrown the stone strong enough to throw it round the world
RayNAiken
It could not have circled the earth that quickly without burning up in the atmosphere. Any slower and it would have fallen and hit the ground short. Any faster it would have continued out into space never to return.
Then again maybe it’s magic.
Opus the Poet
Yeah, don’t you read the “what if?” section of xkcd? The part where real-life science is used on comic-book situations, I check it frequently for new entries.
Andorxor
I think the world in the egg is smaller than earth
Ageisia
Yeah, but if she had it probably would have done some permanent damage to Firedrake there.
Naldru
I believe that the eye that they are seeking is the “third eye” that sees inward, seeing through illusion to truth, seeing one’s own flaws instead of being self-deceived, yada, yada, yada. That would explain the Tarot cards since references on the internet refer to the tarot as a means of strenghening the third eye. The hypothesis will be strengthened if the gatekeeper shows up carrying a crystal ball.
I also think that the locks and obstacles will be overcome by positive character traits, such as courage (stepping on the stone to open the door), honesty (getting her past the stone golems), leadership (she already has two of the others viewing her as competent), observation (noticing the spatial loop), and politeness (the gatekeeper giving her information). I expect further obstacles to be solved by kindness, charity, mercy, humility, loyalty, etc.
DocSavage
Interesting theory, we should find out soon.
Van
Crap, you may be close on that. Anyone here remember the Ultima series? In particular, Ultima IV – Quest of the Avatar? This is starting to sound like the learning the 8 virtues of the avatar and becoming the embodiment of them from the game.
Lycanthromancer
Don’t forget friendship.
It IS magic, after all.
Mr. Bawkbagawk
this thread is now 20% cooler.
Unmaker
So is the voice the return of Grigor the sits-in-a-leaky-boat gnome or is it someone new?
Debra Hanson
Grigor is the “Doorman.” He doesn’t move from his book under the bridge.
This is probably the “Babysitter.”
(Who is likely to be one of Grigor’s relatives, and 84 scores again for knowing Grigor’s name.)
noisyparker
Geez, Firedrake… It isn’t a Star Trek-like loop… it is a Flintstone’s chase scene-like loop.
Van
Try reading “The Witch and the Wombat” and you will understand.
TB
Agreed. I would have said “Hanna-Barbera loop.”
Wanderer
He’s probably referencing the Holodeck, which used a treadmill-like effect to keep people from walking into the camouflaged walls. (That was the story in the pilot episode, at least. Given some of what they do in the Holodeck, it gets a little hard to justify.)
Nodrog
I don’t think 84 could have aimed that rock, so I’m assuming it’s the egg world warping things to hit Firedrake. As for why Firedrake deserved the rock: He’s the one who’s proved he’s not really listening to 84. Conjuror may be dismissing what she said, but he at least listened. Neuro is considering it. Firedrake just heard ‘warping’ and ignored the part about the fact that 84 getting ahead of them by just standing still.
KillerFish
This pocket universe must run on humorous karmic payback.
Matt [in Middletown]
Ludo, summon the rocks!
J. Michael Looney
Ok, no one said it….
84 rocks….
Kaian
Punic wars are one comic to the right. . . o.O
Devlerbat